I am pleased to announce that my research on Jim Crow discrimination and segregation in healthcare has been selected for inclusion in the Delaware Humanities Speakers Bureau catalog for 2024. This opportunity allows me to share my findings with a broad audience and shed light on a largely unexamined aspect of our history.
During the Jim Crow era, discriminatory practices and segregation extended to all aspects of life, including medicine. Black Americans were denied access or received substandard care, leading to health disparities.
Through my research project, I have delved deeply into the struggles endured by African Americans in fighting against this inequality. Utilizing interviews, archival research, hospital records, and nursing school files, I have unearthed a wealth of information that sheds light on the civil rights movement within the medical field.
Here is the program description:
Fighting Jim Crow Discrimination and Segregation in Health Care examines the experiences of African Americans before the passage of modern Civil Rights legislation in the mid-1960s. By highlighting this little-known history within the context of Delmarva and the broader region, I aim to shed light on the contributions of African American doctors, nurses, and caregivers and the advances made within the Black hospital system. This program will explore activists’ struggles in their fight against racism and their relentless pursuit of equality in medicine and health.
This program aims to help participants understand and discuss this unique civil rights narrative, the lesser-known story about the historic struggle for health equality in the United States and the region, and how this legacy affected African Americans. Here are some of the objectives:
Recognize the contributions of unheralded African American trailblazers in the medical professions and allied occupations.
Understand how Black activists, NAACP lawyers, professional organizations, and everyday citizens worked to eliminate discrimination and create equal access.
Describe how litigation and federal law ended the “separate but equal” legal doctrine for hospitals.
Discuss the history and legacy of African American healthcare and consider what we can learn from the struggle to achieve equality.
I am researching the struggle for equality in healthcare, a lesser-known dimension of the civil rights movement. Although the U.S. Supreme Court dealt a blow to “separate but equal” in public schools in 1954, segregation persisted for years in medicine. However, by the mid-1960s, a combination of protests, federal legislation, and judicial rulings had significantly disrupted the Jim Crow practices that had long plagued hospitals, nursing homes, and clinics.1
As I delve into this complex and multifaceted intersection of civil rights and medicine, one area I am concentrating on is the integration of Delaware nursing schools, a significant achievement for the civil rights movement. During the 1950s, nursing schools commonly practiced segregation, limiting opportunities to pursue careers in the caring professions and make meaningful contributions to their communities.
Delaware Schools
In 1950, Delaware had seven nursing schools--four in Wilmington, one in New Castle County, and two downstate. These programs excluded Blacks leading to a severe shortage of professional African American nurses in the state.2
The National League of Nursing Education produced this 1950 list:
Delaware State, Farnhurst, established in 1929, 13 students
Beebe, Lewes, 1921, 10 students;
Milford Memorial, 1926, 21 students;
Delaware, Wilmington, 1897, 160 students;
Memorial, Wilmington, 1888, 92 students;
St. Francis, Wilmington, 1924, 66 students;
Wilmington General, Wilmington, 1910, 50 Students
To gain insight into nursing schools in the City, I am examining records of three Wilmington hospitals. The materials archived at the Lewis B. Flinn Medical Library at Christiana Care offer valuable insight into the policies, practices, and enrollment of these institutions during the mid-20th century.
In 1954, a significant civil rights healthcare milestone occurred in Delaware. Late that year, Wilmington Memorial Hospital Superintendent, Grace L. Little, announced a groundbreaking decision to open admission to the school for qualified candidates regardless of race. This decision marked a significant turning point in the fight for integrated medical education in Delaware, overturning in one institution the discriminatory policies that had long excluded Black students from the program.3
In the fall of 1955, when a new class began at Memorial Hospital, two African American students, Ive Brown of Felton and Carrie Thomas of Chester, PA, proudly stood alongside their classmates for the annual “probie” photo.4,5
A Civil Rights Healthcare Milestone
For the first time, African American students were admitted to a registered nurses training program in Delaware. When the hospital held its 65th graduation in 1958, Carrie Thomas and fifteen other young women had completed the course of study for registered nurses. Ive Brown graduated from a one-year practical nursing course at Brown Vocational High School.6.
This milestone, a significant step forward in the struggle for equality in healthcare, contributed to Delaware’s civil rights movement. My work on other dimensions of the civil rights struggle in medicine continues in Delaware.
For additional photos on integrating nursing schools in Delaware, see this album on Facebook.
National League of Nursing Education, “State-Approved Schools of Nursing: Schools Meeting Minimum Requirements Set by Law and Board Rules in the Various States and Territories, (New York), 1950[↩]
Hospital to Accept Nursing Students Regardless of Race,” Morning News, December 7, 1954[↩]
“32 Student Nurses Start Memorial Class, Journal-Every Evening, September 7, 1955[↩]
“Probie Class Photo,” 1958, Wilmington Memorial Hospital[↩]
“15 Graduate at Memorial,” Morning News, September 4, 1958[↩]
Memorial Hospital, Probies-Class of 1958, photograph (Wilmington, DE, 1955), Lewis B. FlInn Medical Library, Christiana Care, Newark, DE.[↩]
For years, I have studied African American health care, seeking to understand the history of practices before Black Americans gained access to mainstream medicine. This fieldwork has given me the opportunity to interview nurses, aides, physicians, and tradition bearers in communities across Maryland, Delaware, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey.
So when the Association for the Study of African American Life and History selected “Black Health and Wellness” as its 2022 theme, a couple of organizations asked me to discuss the contributions of two medical pioneers in Maryland.
Dr. Stansbury in Havre de Grace
In the 20th century, African American physicians established practices in more communities. In Harford County, Dr. George T. Stansbury opened his office in Havre de Grace in 1950. But the Howard University College of Medicine graduate could not admit patients to Harford Memorial Hospital, which maintained a segregated ward.
In 1960, a tragedy occurred at the hospital when the staff initially denied a young Black woman full access to all the labor and delivery facilities after medical complications developed. Dr. Stansbury spent the night with the patient, doing what he could to save the newborn and mother. But, both passed away. The father sued, and in 1963, the hospital agreed to integrate.
For the Cecil County Chapter of the NAACP, I talked about Dr. James L. Johnson. The graduate of Meharry Medical College, a Freedmen’s Bureau-era School in Nashville, TN, came to Elkton to open his office in 1934. When Dr. Johnson started practicing medicine in the middle of the Great Depression, the county’s health care system was segregated, like every other aspect of life in Cecil County. To admit patients to Union Hospital, Doctor Johnson made arrangements with one of the community’s white physicians.
The segregated system for patient care remained in place until landmark civil rights decisions in the 1960s forced changes. The 1964 Civil Rights Act, hospital desegregation rulings in the federal courts, the passage of Medicare and Medicaid, and other initiatives created a Civil Rights era in health care. Consequently, the separate wards system ended in Elkton as Doctor Johnson received full staff privileges. The respected physician maintained a busy practice until the 1970s.
It is important to remember those who paved the way for the current generation and the difficulties they faced.
Since the nation crossed a grim milestone of one million covid deaths on May 17, 2022, I have been examining how the toll from this pandemic compares to the influenza outbreak of 1918-19 in Harford County.1
COVID-19
According to the Harford County Health Department, the first COVID-19 case was identified in the county on March 8, 2020, and the first virus-related death occurred on April 13, 2020.2,3 Over the next 26-months, the mortality count ticked upward, the disease taking 585 lives as of May 25, 2022. This results in 2.22 COVID-19 deaths per 1,000 people since the county has a population of nearly 263,000.4,5
Influenza Pandemic of 1918-19
One-hundred-four years earlier another mysterious pathogen ripped across Harford County. This time about 29,000 people lived here as reports of puzzling pneumonia cases trickled in slowly in the middle of September 1918. But soon a bewildering cluster of influenza cases hit Aberdeen Proving Ground and Edgewood Arsenal. As the calendar turned to October the contagion spread, taking a deadly toll as it pummeled Harford County.6
The first fatal influenza case involved 33-year-old Hall Wesley Barefoot of Bedford, PA, an electrician on September 24, 1918. He died at Havre de Grace Hospital. The following day, on September 25, Private Joseph Augustus of Fall River MA, 28, a pipefitter at Edgewood Arsenal, died at the base hospital.7,8,9,6
Once the pathogen exploded locally, many residents became gravely ill, and an appalling number of deaths occurred. By the end of 1918, Harford County had recorded 474 excess deaths, a 132 percent increase in mortality over the previous six-year average. Another concentrated wave hit in the winter of 1919, as the virus kept Maryland in its clutches. Over that frosty season, the county reported 63 additional excess deaths, an increase of eighteen percent. This metric, excess deaths, measures how many lives were lost beyond what would have been expected.10
Flu Swept Across Harford County
During the time the novel pathogen raged across the county in 1918-19, a rough indicator is that of these 537 excess deaths, the Maryland Board of Health attributed 450 to influenza or pneumonia. This gave the county a virus-related death rate of about 15.5 per 1,000 people and an overall death rate of 28.6 for all causes in 1918 and 14.4 in 1919. For the six-year average before 1918, the annual total mortality rate was 13.411.
Harford County had the second-highest mortality rate per 1,000 in Maryland in 1918, while Anne Arundel County ranked the highest.
County
Total Death per 1,000 in 1918
Anne Arundel
42.7
Harford
28.6
Baltimore City
25.7
Kent
24.1
Talbot
23.3
Cecil
21.8
Incidence Rate — Deaths per 1,000 in Maryland in 1918
Comparison
While it is difficult to estimate the precise toll of the disease over 100-years-ago, the excess deaths above the expected mortality level provide one measure for assessing suddenly shifting health outcomes. The county recorded 537 excess deaths when the population stood at just over 29,000.
Comparing events that occurred more than a century apart has many perils. For example, the population of Harford County in 1918 was about eleven percent of what it is today, meaning that influenza cut a much bigger, lethal swath through the county in a short, concentrated period of a few months. COVID-19 has taken more lives than the influenza pandemic did in terms of the raw mortality count, but the population is far larger.
During three waves of influenza from 1918 to 1919, there were 537 excess and 450 virus-related deaths. Thus far, in 2022, there have been 585 COVID-related losses and the data on excess deaths has not been developed. Also, the COVID numbers continue to tick upward as the pandemic is not over. In 1918-19, the death rate for influenza-related cases was about 15.5 cases per 1,000 people, while the rate for the current pandemic is 2.2.
Measure
1918-19
2020-Present
Excess Deaths
537
TBD
Virus-Related
450
585
Total Deaths
1,275
TBD
Virus-Related Deaths per/1000
15.5
2.2
County Population
29,086
262,977
Estimate of key pandemic metrics for Harford County: Comparing COVID-19 with the flu pandemic of 1918-19
Military Installations
One confounding element for a comparative epidemiological study of 1918-19 in Harford County centers on the establishment of Aberdeen Providing Ground (APG) and Edgewood Arsenal. APG formally opened on December 1, 1917, on some 69,000 acres. At its height during World War I, APG had a population of five thousand military personnel and three thousand civilian workers, according to the Historic Inventory of the Property. Edgewood had around 9,210 personnel.12
As construction workers and military personnel showed up to hastily build the cantonments, these locations where a mobile population congregated served as an incubator for spreading the contagion throughout rural Harford County. Also, this increase in transient population does not appear to have been included in Maryland Board of Health population estimates.
Most of the 1918-19 deaths in Harford County — 44 percent — occurred at the Government Filling Station (Edgewood Arsenal). Aberdeen Proving Ground accounted for 38-percent of the deaths, with the remaining 18 percent occurring across the county.
Endnotes
Carla K. Johnson, Associated Press, US Deaths from COVID hit 1 million, less than 2 1/2 years in[↩]
Barry Glassman, Press Release, Weekly Update on COVID-19, March 20, 2020[↩]
Barry Glassman, Press Release, Harford’s First Confirmed COVID-19 Death, April 17, 2020[↩]
Johns Hopkins University, COVID-19 Dashboard, Center for Systems Science and Engineering[↩]